Thursday, January 26, 2006

OPINION: Look past Bali bombers for true picture of Indonesia

I have just spent a couple of hours experiencing the lights and sounds and costumes of a ballet. But this was no Swan Lake. It was the performance of an ancient Hindu epic known as the Ramayana.

The costumes and masks of the cast were phenomenal, as were the accompanying orchestra and singers.

The ballet was performed in the shadow of one of the oldest Hindu temples on earth.

But what made the performance amazing was not the music, the instruments or costumes. It was that this ballet was being performed as a cultural performance in the world's largest Muslim country.

The Ramayana is performed regularly to Muslim audiences across this archipelago, 88 per cent of whose population regard themselves as Muslim.

When our delegation of young Australian Muslims arrived at the temple grounds, in the Indonesian university town of Yogyakarta, we were expecting to witness a distant relic of Indonesia's ancient pre-Islamic past.

Instead, we were greeted with the traditional Arabic greeting of "assalamu alaykum" (peace be with you).

It was unclear whether our hosts were Hindu or Muslim. But, without doubt, most of the actors were Muslim, as were most of the audience.

Many were young couples for whom a trip to a Hindu ballet was a culturally appropriate night out. Many were women wearing headscarves.

For Indonesian Muslims, Hindu and Buddhist influences are celebrated as part of their mainstream culture.

Islam arrived in Indonesia through traders and was spread peacefully by Chinese and Yemeni merchants.

It adapted to existing Hindu and Buddhist cultures and co-opted the symbols of these faiths.

In India, the birthplace of the Ramayana hero has become the scene of conflict.

Hindus claim the medieval Muslim king Babur built a mosque on the site, destroying an existing Hindu shrine.

The dispute over the mosque and its destruction by Hindu extremists in 1992 has led to religious riots in which tens of thousands have been killed across northern India.

But while the Ramayana hero is at the centre of conflict in India, Indonesian Muslim actors take part in a Ramayana ballet with a largely Muslim audience.

In Jakarta, our delegation visited Indonesia's largest mosque - the Masjid Istiqlal (Independence Mosque), which holds up to 50,000 people.

Before the traditional call to prayer, a drum is beaten, consistent with traditional Javanese Hindu culture. Women and men enter the mosque from the same entrance and pray in the same pavilion without any curtain.

It seems the largest Islamic country in the world is far more liberal in gender matters than other Muslim cultures in which women are often banned from the mosque or relegated to a separate area.

Across the road from the Independence Mosque is Jakarta's Catholic Cathedral. On Sundays, the cathedral's car park is quickly filled and the mosque authorities let Catholics park on the mosque premises.

In the post-Suharto era, the Chinese New Year has become a public holiday and is even being celebrated in some Indonesian mosques.

Perhaps Muslims in other parts of the world can learn from Indonesia's example.

Indonesia may be seen as a hotbed of extremism and anti-Western feeling. But whatever Indonesians may think of Western governments, their attitude toward all cultures and faiths appears far more open than many Western countries that claim to be multicultural.

The Ramayana Muslim artists are more representative of mainstream Indonesian Islam than the Bali bombers.

*Irfan Yusuf is a Sydney lawyer visiting Indonesia as part of a delegation of Young Australian Muslims. This article was first published in the New Zealand Herald on 26 January 2006.

Words © 2006 Irfan Yusuf


correctingirfan said...

mainstream Islam? tsk tsk.

Anonymous said...
This comment has been removed by a blog administrator.
Anonymous said...

.. their attitude toward all cultures and faiths appears far more open than many Western countries that claim to be multicultural.

Name one Western country that is less open than Indonesia. All of them are more open. You are insane.

Anonymous said...

Anonymous @ 7:59pm, I can name one such Western country. Israel.

Woops, sorry. I forgot. You Young Liberal worshippers of Opus Dei hate Jews even more than Moslems.

Irfan said...

Anonymous, my trip was paid for by myself and millions of other taxpayers (through funding provided by DFAT). I'm not sure if you know what it is like to be a taxpayer, but the program is designed to build more person-2-person contacts between Indonesia and Australia.

Anonymous said...

What did Indonesians think of an obese arrogant black turd who has obviously been stealing all the food while they starve? DFAT apparently has too much money and not suprisingly you had your pig face in the trough. The poor bastard who has to sit next to your stinking corpse on the aeroplane! Why don't you stay in Indonesia? Someone who thinks they are an instant expert after one visit to Ramayana is obviously well qualified to be President of Indonesia as well.

Anonymous said...
This comment has been removed by a blog administrator.
Anonymous said...

Irf I misjudged you. I'm very very worried for Australias Muslims if you honestly believe Indonesia is more open than Western countries.

Survey results published in The Jakarta Post.

If this is the standard of our Muslim brothers and sisters self analysis! What hope have we got? Sure there are some Aussie nutters twist and distort out of fear and hate. But you Irf? You're supposed to be better than that.

I've learned something recently regarding humiliation in Islam how it is fundamentally against the Muslim faith. Compared with Christ who willingly suffered the humiliation of the Cross for us.

Look I'm just trying to understand why you would say what you said? Its patently false.

Anonymous said...

DFAT clearly had difficulty finding appropriate participants for this junket. They really scraped the bottom of the barrell with you Irf.

It seems to be a common thread witrh Australians travelling to Indonesia, Schapelle Corby, Michelle Leslie, The Bali Nine and Irfan Yusuf. They all devalue Australian Citizenship and bring our great nation into disrepute with their antics and utter disregard for patriotism and decorum.

Shame on DFAT.

Anonymous said...

Great to see Alex Hawke and his cronies have learnt how to write. Now their next challenge is to learn how to read!

Anonymous said...

What sort of personality is it that is arrogant, never admits a mistake, never says sorry and who's opinion is never wrong.

Anonymous said...

I want to bash you to death with a large ham. Then I want to bury the ham with you so you don't go to heaven.

Anonymous said...

Palestinian killing Palestinian is a new development. Let's celebrate it. Jews killing Palestinians was getting boring. More dead Palestinians please.

Anonymous said...

Is Alex Hawke your ex-boyfriend?

Anonymous said...
This comment has been removed by a blog administrator.
Anonymous said...
This comment has been removed by a blog administrator.
Anonymous said...
This comment has been removed by a blog administrator.